Edward Smith

Personal life

Edward John Smith was born on 27 January 1850 on Well Street in Hanley, Staffordshire, England, the son of Edward Smith, a potter, and Catherine Hancock (née Marsh). His parents had married on 2 August 1841 in Shelton, Staffordshire, and later kept a shop.

He attended the British School in Etruria, Staffordshire, until the age of 13, after which he left to operate a steam hammer at the Etruria Forge. In 1867, aged 17, he followed his half‑brother, Joseph Hancock, to Liverpool, where Hancock was serving as captain of a sailing vessel. Smith began his own maritime apprenticeship that year aboard Senator Weber, owned by A. Gibson & Co. of Liverpool.

Marriage and residence

On 13 January 1887, Smith married Sarah Eleanor Pennington (most commonly known by her middle name) at St Oswald's Church, Winwick, Lancashire. Their daughter, Helen Melville Smith, was born on 2 April 1898 in Waterloo, Liverpool. When the White Star line transferred its transatlantic operations from Liverpool to Southampton in 1907, the family relocated to a red‑brick, twin‑gabled house named Woodhead on Winn Road, Highfield, Southampton.

Family

Smith's mother lived in Runcorn, Cheshire, where Smith himself intended to retire. She died there in 1893. His half-sister, Thyrza, died in 1921. Smith's widow died in 1931 after being struck by a taxi in London.

Smith's daughter married Sidney Russell-Cooke in January 1922, and they had twins in 1923, Simon and Priscilla. Simon, a pilot in the Royal Air Force, was killed in 1944 during the Second World War, and Priscilla died from polio three years later; neither had children. Helen died in 1973.

Career

Early commands

Smith joined the White Star Line in March 1880 as Fourth Officer of SS Celtic. He served aboard the company's liners to Australia and New York City, where he rose quickly in status. In 1887, he received his first White Star command, Republic. Smith failed his first navigation exam, but passed on his second attempt the following week, and in February 1888 earned his Extra Master's Certificate. He joined the Royal Naval Reserve, receiving a commission as a lieutenant, which entitled him to add "RNR" after his name. In wartime, he could be called upon to serve in the Royal Navy. His ships were entitled to fly the Blue Ensign of the RNR; British merchant vessels generally flew the Red Ensign. Smith retired from the RNR in 1905 with the rank of Commander.

Later commands

Smith was Majestic's captain for nine years from 1895. When the Second Boer War broke out in 1899, Majestic was called upon to transport British Imperial troops to the Cape Colony. Smith made two trips to South Africa, both without incident, and in 1903 King Edward VII awarded him the Transport Medal with the "South Africa" clasp. Smith was regarded as a "safe captain". As he rose in seniority, he gained a following among passengers, some of whom sailed the Atlantic only on a ship he captained.

Smith became known as the "Millionaires' Captain". From 1904, he commanded the White Star Line's newest ships on their maiden voyages. In 1904, he was given command of what was then the largest ship in the world, Baltic. Her maiden voyage from Liverpool to New York, sailing 29 June 1904, passed without incident. After three years with Baltic, Smith was given his second new "big ship", Adriatic. Her maiden voyage also passed without incident. During his command of Adriatic, Smith received the long service Decoration for Officers of the Royal Naval Reserve (RD).

As one of the world's most experienced sea captains, Smith was chosen to take first command of the lead ship in a new class of ocean liners, RMS Olympic – again the largest vessel in the world at that time. The maiden voyage from Southampton to New York concluded on 21 June 1911, but as the ship was docking in New York harbour, a minor incident occurred. Docking at Pier 59 under the harbour pilot's command, Olympic was being assisted by twelve tugs when one was caught in her backwash, spun around, collided with the larger ship, and for a moment was trapped under Olympic's stern before working free and limping to the docks.

Hawke incident

On 20 September 1911, Olympic's first major mishap occurred during a collision with a British warship HMS Hawke, in which the warship lost her prow. Although the collision left two of Olympic's compartments flooded and one of her propeller shafts twisted, she was able to limp back to Southampton. At the inquiry, the Royal Navy blamed Olympic, finding that her massive size generated a suction that pulled Hawke into her side. Smith had been on the bridge during the events.

The Hawke incident was a financial disaster for White Star, and the out-of-service time for the liner made matters worse. Olympic returned to Belfast and, to speed repairs, Harland and Wolff delayed Titanic's completion to use one of her propeller shafts and other parts for Olympic. Back at sea in February 1912, Olympic lost a propeller blade and again returned for emergency repairs. To get her back to service immediately, Harland and Wolff again pulled resources from Titanic, delaying her maiden voyage from 20 March to 10 April.

Titanic

Despite the past trouble, Smith was again appointed to command the newest ship in the Olympic class when Titanic left Southampton for her maiden voyage. On 30 March, Smith left the Olympic at Southampton and made a quick trip to Belfast. He arrived in time to take command of Titanic on 1 April, relieving Herbert James Haddock. On 9 April, as Titanic was docked in Southampton, Smith went ashore and stayed overnight at his home on Winn Road to spend time with his wife and daughter. Some sources state that he intended to retire after Titanic's maiden voyage, in order to spend more time with his family.

On 10 April 1912, Smith left his home at 7:00 a.m. The local paperboy, 11-year-old Albert Benham, recalled Smith saying "Alright son, I'll take my paper." Smith proceeded to Berth 44, arriving at 7:30 a.m. At 8:00 a.m., he was onboard Titanic to prepare for the Board of Trade muster. Artist Norman Wilkinson, acquainted with Smith, asked a quartermaster for Smith's whereabouts; the quartermaster took him to the Captain, who was in his cabin. Smith welcomed Wilkinson warmly but said he was too busy to conduct a personal tour, asking a purser to show them around instead. On the bridge, Smith received the sailing report from Chief Officer Henry Wilde and finished his paperwork. After departure at noon, the water displaced by Titanic caused the laid-up New York to break from her moorings and swing towards Titanic. Quick action by the tender Vulcan, which moved between the ships, averted a premature end to the maiden voyage.

On the evening of 12 April, Smith dined with Bruce Ismay in the first-class restaurant on B Deck. The following evening, 13 April, in the reception room, Smith entertained a party by telling them the "ship could be cut crosswise in three places and each piece would float". On 14 April, Titanic's wireless operators received six messages from other ships warning of drifting ice, which passengers had begun to notice during the afternoon.

Although the crew was aware of ice in the vicinity, they did not reduce speed and continued at 22 knots (41 km/h; 25 mph). Titanic's high speed in waters where ice had been reported was later criticised as reckless, but it reflected standard maritime practice. According to Fifth Officer Harold Lowe, the custom was "to go ahead and depend upon the lookouts in the crow's nest and the watch on the bridge to 'pick up' the ice in time to avoid hitting it."

Death

Conflicting accounts of Smith's death emerged after the disaster. Initial rumours claimed that Smith shot himself. Some press reports speculated that he chose to go down with his ship and died on the bridge when it was engulfed by the sea. The New York Herald of 19 April 1912 quoted Robert Williams Daniel as having seen Smith on the bridge, waist-high in water. Daniel's account is unlikely, as he jumped from the stern as the ship sank.

Smith had made statements suggesting that he might go down with his ship if confronted with a disaster. A friend, Dr Williams, asked him what would happen if the Adriatic struck ice and was damaged. "Some of us would go to the bottom with the ship," Smith replied. A boyhood friend, William Jones, said, "Ted Smith passed away just as he would have loved to do. To stand on the bridge of his vessel and go down with her was characteristic of all his actions when we were boys together." This belief has been perpetuated in portrayals of the disaster, including the 1958 film A Night to Remember and the 1997 film Titanic.

Alternatively, Smith may have jumped overboard from the bridge – after entering it from the starboard side – after giving the order to abandon ship to crew on the port side. While working to free Collapsible B, Bride said he saw Smith dive from the bridge into the sea just as Collapsible B was levered off the roof of the officers' quarters. This is supported by first-class passenger Mrs. Eleanor Widener, who was in Lifeboat No. 4, and second-class passenger William John Mellors, who survived on Collapsible B; both stated that Smith jumped from the bridge.

Mess steward Cecil Fitzpatrick also claimed to have seen Smith on the bridge a few minutes before the final plunge. He said Smith was with Andrews. They put on lifebelts; Smith told Andrews, "We cannot stay any longer; she is going!" Fitzpatrick saw Andrews and Smith both jump overboard just as the water reached the bridge.

There is circumstantial evidence that Smith may have died in the water near the overturned Collapsible B. Colonel Archibald Gracie reported that an unknown swimmer approached the capsized and overcrowded boat. One of the men onboard told him, "Hold on to what you have, old boy. One more of you aboard would sink us all." The swimmer replied, in a powerful voice, "All right boys. Good luck and God bless you." He did not ask to come aboard, but encouraged the occupants, saying "Good boys! Good lads!" with "the voice of authority". Fireman Walter Hurst tried to reach him with an oar, but the man had died. Hurst said he was certain the swimmer was Smith. Gracie said he heard men on Collapsible B, including stoker Harry Senior and entrée cook Isaac Maynard, say that the swimmer was Smith.

Legacy

Smith's wife wrote a letter of condolence to family members and friends of those who died in the sinking, which was posted outside the White Star Line offices in London on 18 April: "To my poor fellow sufferers: My heart overflows with grief for you. I am laden with sorrow that you should be weighed down with this terrible burden that has been thrust upon us. I pray God will comfort all."

A statue of Smith, sculpted by Kathleen Scott, widow of Antarctic explorer Robert Falcon Scott, was unveiled in July 1914 at the western end of the Museum Gardens in Beacon Park, Lichfield. The pedestal is made from Cornish granite and the figure is bronze. Lichfield was chosen because Smith was a Staffordshire man and the city was the centre of the diocese. The statue cost £740 (£70,000 with inflation), raised through local and national contributions.

In 2010, as part of the "Parks for People" programme, the statue was restored and the green patina removed at a cost of £16,000. In 2011, an unsuccessful campaign sought to move the statue to Smith's hometown of Hanley.

Smith had already been commemorated in Hanley Town Hall with a plaque reading: "This tablet is dedicated to the memory of Commander Edward John Smith RD, RNR. Born in Hanley, 27th Jany 1850, died at sea, 15th April 1912. Whilst in command of the White Star SS Titanic that great ship struck an iceberg in the Atlantic Ocean during the night and speedily sank with nearly all who were on board. Captain Smith having done all man could do for the safety of passengers and crew remained at his post on the sinking ship until the end. His last message to the crew was 'Be British.'"

The plaque was removed in 1961, given to a local school, and later returned to the Town Hall, where it was remounted inside the building in 1978. The Titanic Brewery in Burslem, Stoke-on-Trent, is named in honour of Smith. As a member of the Royal Naval Reserve, Smith wore his two decorations when in uniform: the Decoration for Officers of the Royal Naval Reserve and the Transport Medal.

Portrayals

On screen, Smith has been portrayed by:

Otto Rippert (1912) (In Nacht und Eis)

Otto Wernicke (1943) (Titanic)

Brian Aherne (1953) (Titanic)

Noel Drayton (1955) You Are There: The Sinking of the Titanic (TV episode, 22 May 1955)

Clarence Derwent (1956) (Kraft Television Theatre) (A Night to Remember)

Laurence Naismith (1958) (A Night to Remember)

Michael Rennie (1966–1967) (The Time Tunnel), 2 episodes (fictionalised as "Captain Malcolm Smith")

Season 1: Episode 1: Rendezvous With Yesterday

Season 1: Episode 30: Town of Terror

Harry Andrews (1979) (S.O.S. Titanic) (TV Movie)

Hugh Reilly (1983) (Voyagers!) (Voyagers of the Titanic)

Harry Andrews (1996) (Danielle Steel's No Greater Love)

George C. Scott (1996) (Titanic) (TV Miniseries)

John Cunningham (1997) (Titanic) (Broadway Musical)

Bernard Hill (1997) (Titanic)

Ron Rutherford (1998) (Titanic: Secrets Revealed)

Frank von Kuegelgen (1999) (The Legend of the Titanic) (Animated Film)